sikacz wrote: Mon Dec 18, 2023 6:31 pm
sig230 wrote: Mon Dec 18, 2023 6:03 pm
sikacz wrote: Mon Dec 18, 2023 5:47 pm
That really isn’t a reason to make it worse.
But we live in a world of reality rather than wishful thinking.
The evidence shows that Americans claim to believe in a rule of law but show that they obey the law only when it doesn't interfere with their desires.
The evidence shows that the courts issue mutually exclusive and contradictory rulings.
The evidence show that states disregard federal laws and rulings with impunity.
Reality can be a bitch but it is still reality. Does Texas have a new Attorney General to replace the one who lost just about every case?
Your position implies exactly what was posted earlier, allow states and courts to ignore rule and higher precedents. In the end there really is no need for any of us to comply with any law. That is the “reality” you are speaking about. If that is the case it doesn’t matter which party is in power or who is president. It doesn’t even matter if one votes or not because no law needs to be obeyed and all agreements are meaningless. It only matters who is standing last. That is what your position leads to, it’s your realism.
Ignoring laws and set precedents is not realism, it’s anarchy.
Learn to read.
It is not my position but rather a summary of the available evidence.
Look at the subject of this thread. We have two different courts each issuing a mutually exclusive and contradictory finding.
We exist in a reality were Justices are selected and enabled on a political basis at all levels.
Look at the reality on the highways. Does everyone obey speed limits, refrain from talking or texting while driving, obeying stop signs, traffic lights, signal lane changing, stay in one's lane?
Look at people walking. Are they paying attention to conditions or looking at their iPhone or isolated from their surroundings listening to music or pod casts wearing ear buds?
We do live in a society that believes in the Rule of Law as long as the Law does not cause personal inconvenience or prevent someone from doing what they want to do.
Look at our Governors latest decree authorizing State and local police to arrest immigrants.
It's not my position, it is reality and so far there does not seem to be any model, method, mechanism, process or procedure that has any realistic chance of changing the current reality.