FrontSight wrote: Tue Jan 17, 2023 3:31 pm
With a premium bullet, if the only thing I had was a .25-06 and someone wants to take me on a hunt for brown bear...I'm going hunting. I'm not saying its optimal, but sufficient. I have seen .25 cal Barnes X bullets make short work of rather large elk. I have a friend in Alaska who sometimes guides on Kodiak island who killed two with a .257 Roberts, and dozens of Caribou with the same .257; quarterbores can get it done. Again...I'm not going to not hunt just because my rifle is a .25-06.
Just saying from a hunting standpoint, there isn't enough difference in performance on game in the field between .25-06 and .30-06 to even bother with.
On non-predatory species, I would agree. Deer of all species, including elk, tend to run from you. Bears, however, are predatory and will turn on you with those big fangs, claws, and super-strong arms/legs if they get the chance, especially the big browns, grizzlies, and polar bears. That's where I would call for something bigger than a .25-06. But for a caribou, sure.
We could get into the chambering wars, of course (naturally, the 7mm-08 is better than anything else, I don't care WHAT the 6.5 Creedmoor ninnies say! :-D), but what matters is what you're comfortable hunting with. I'm just glad that Weatherby is continuing to chamber for the effective ol' granddad, the .30-06. It remains as popular as it is for very good reason, and it ain't just nostalgia.