Almost every round failed to extract in two High Standards and an FN Browning Medalist. In an S&W 17-2 revolver, the back of the fired cases would stretch out just enough to interfere with the cylinder advancing, and it took a real hand punch on the extractor rod to kick them out.
I mic'ed it to compare to CCI SV, no dimensional differences that jump out at me. I'm wondering if it is that strange groove around the middle of the casing (I think that's the "target crimp" that they mention on the box), or if the brass is softer or thinner? I measured a couple of spent cases and a couple of spent CCI SV cases, diameter wasn't any greater.
Annoying, because the group you see in this photo was at 5 shots at 12 yards from the FN Browning Medalist, basically using it as a single shot. I had to use a rod to punch out the case after each shot because they jammed in the case too tight for the extractor to pull them. Note that the gun was clean when I started, (I'd fired only 20 or 30 rounds since the last good cleaning) and after this I fired 25 rounds, CCI SV and Topshot (a generic brand, I think S&B makes it) without a hitch (and without the same accuracy).
