Page 1 of 1

Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacking

Posted: Mon Sep 09, 2019 2:42 pm
by wpkato
https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/cri ... story.html

Illinois/Chicago centric story but it can be correlated to other metro areas. These CCL holders give the rest of us a bad rep and should have never had CCLs to begin with if they don't have the maturity, judgement or responsibility.

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Mon Sep 09, 2019 3:02 pm
by Eris
This is why I think CCL training needs to be better than it is. The class I took to get my Texas permit said essentially nothing about when it is and is not appropriate to use your gun, and I think that is a big problem. Too many people (not necessarily the majority) who carry think they are allowed to use their guns in lots of circumstances where they really need to be showing restraint. At the very least, these people need to be educated. I'd like to see concealed carry classes teach incidents like the one in the article so that potential carriers know that if they make the wrong decision they could end up in jail. That won't stop the real hotheads, but it might give more normal people a reason to pause and think before they escalate a situation to deadly violence.

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Tue Sep 10, 2019 1:54 am
by NegativeApproach
This article is a hack hit job by Bloomberg flunkies.

The article doesn't conveniently doesn't mention that there are more shootings in the average Chicago weekend, than they are talking about in this front page Tribune article.

Why doesn't THAT get reported on?

This is anti-gun propaganda passing itself off as reporting.

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Tue Sep 10, 2019 9:14 am
by highdesert
I agree with Eris about tightening up on training, but the article focuses on the problem cases. The Trib database has many cases where CCL was used correctly.
...a 63-year-old man with a concealed carry license shot a 16-year-old boy who was trying to rob him in the South Chicago neighborhood. The boy was hit in the knee. Police said the boy's gun turned out to be a replica.


...a man from Mount Prospect was driving in the 700 block of North Clark Street in Chicago when he saw three people attacking a man. The driver got out, walked toward the attackers -- all wearing surgical masks -- and pulled out his gun to scare them away. The man had a CCL, according to police.


...Dave Thomas heard screams in his Oswego apartment building, grabbed his AR-15 rifle and ran down the hall. He confronted a man who was stabbing another man and scared him off. Thomas is a gun instructor with a CCL.


...a man pulled into a lot on the Far South Side. A person standing nearby pointed a gun at him and tried to rob the man, who held a CCL. The man drew his own gun, and shot and seriously wounded the robber, officials said.


...CCL holder Diane McIntire placed her gun in the center console as she parked her truck at a Moline mall where she planned to buy vitamins. Moments later, she was approached by a stranger with a knife who cut her and demanded she drive him to a rural area. After driving with the man for dozens of miles, she was able to grab her gun and the man ran off. She drove herself to a hospital, officials said.


...a man walked into an auto parts store in Dolton, pulled a gun and demanded money from two workers and a customer, police said. The workers began running and the robber began firing. As he turned to leave the store, the customer -- a CCL holder -- pulled his gun and seriously wounded the robber, police said.


...a man in his 20s was walking down the street on the South Side when a 19-year-old man pulled out a gun and tried to rob him, according to police. The man, a CCL holder, pulled out his own gun and shot the robber in the head, killing him, police said. The CCL holder was hit in the hip.
https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct- ... story.html

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Tue Sep 10, 2019 3:26 pm
by VodoundaVinci
In Illinois we have about the toughest CCL law in the US - 16 hours of training and a shooting test of 30 rounds to pass. I don't think Illinois recognizes any other States CCL. If I had my way, Illinois CCL standards would be universal. One should have to shoot and hit what they shoot at as well as pass written tests about the use of deadly force.

Still I had folks in my class that either didn't pass or did so marginally and I'd hate to think they own guns let alone carry one. I spend a lot of time at the local range helping other CCL folks find the right holsters and practice drawing and shooting. I was shocked at the number of folks who have a CCL but don't carry because they can't find a holster, weapon that hides on their body, or decide what style of carry works for them.

VooDoo

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Tue Sep 10, 2019 9:17 pm
by Antiquus
Michigan was similar, and must include an hour of instruction from a LEO, judge, or member of the bar about legalities of carrying and especially use of deadly force. It opens a lot of eyes.

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Tue Sep 10, 2019 11:37 pm
by Eris
Antiquus wrote: Tue Sep 10, 2019 9:17 pm Michigan was similar, and must include an hour of instruction from a LEO, judge, or member of the bar about legalities of carrying and especially use of deadly force. It opens a lot of eyes.
That's the kind of thing I wish we had in Texas.

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Wed Sep 11, 2019 11:11 am
by TrueTexan
Years ago when I gt my CHL the instructor did cover the egalities of carrying and especially use of deadly force. Even giving example where using deadly force is legal but not advised because of civil suits. Also knowing the situation before drawing the gun. Example given. Your filling up your car at a 7-11 then a women runs out of the store with two men chasing here yelling at her. you see one has a gun but is not using it. you draw your gun and tell them to stop. Then you find out you're not a hero but have interfered with undercover police officer and DEA office on a major drug bust gone bad. You are now in deep crap. Best solution you use your cell phone call 911 rather than pull your gun.

They also had a person there from what is now US Law Shield to explain what they had to offer.

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Wed Sep 11, 2019 3:10 pm
by DMac

Eris wrote:This is why I think CCL training needs to be better than it is.
What training short of boot camp would be better? You need to take a 16hr course and qualify with a pistol already.

I hate to be that guy, but local newspapers here are kinda trash. The Sun Times and Tribune both like to cherry pick data and monger fear. The state just got concealed carry, so now they have a new attack victim.

I have lived in Chicago most of my life and studied PoliSci here; I will keep saying this: All of the problems with this city comes back to hyper poverty and segregation. Some of the suburbs have similar problems as the city, Dolton being one that used to be an affluent neighborhood, but it's more crime ridden.

Not guns, not gentrification, not spray paint (banned in Chicago), not whatever mayor we have. Poverty and the fallout fun it create gangs and idiots like this.

Also gun crime is down btw in the state, including Chicago since we got CCW. Not saying it's correlated, just saying.



Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Wed Sep 11, 2019 3:49 pm
by Eris
DMac wrote: Wed Sep 11, 2019 3:10 pm
Eris wrote:This is why I think CCL training needs to be better than it is.
What training short of boot camp would be better? You need to take a 16hr course and qualify with a pistol already.

I hate to be that guy, but local newspapers here are kinda trash. The Sun Times and Tribune both like to cherry pick data and monger fear. The state just got concealed carry, so now they have a new attack victim.

I have lived in Chicago most of my life and studied PoliSci here; I will keep saying this: All of the problems with this city comes back to hyper poverty and segregation. Some of the suburbs have similar problems as the city, Dolton being one that used to be an affluent neighborhood, but it's more crime ridden.

Not guns, not gentrification, not spray paint (banned in Chicago), not whatever mayor we have. Poverty and the fallout fun it create gangs and idiots like this.

Also gun crime is down btw in the state, including Chicago since we got CCW. Not saying it's correlated, just saying.
When I wrote that I was mostly thinking about the rather paltry "training" required in Texas. I'm not familiar with the Illinois requirements.

To be clear, what I would like to see is training on when deadly force is legally allowed to be used, and actually give people a real test on it to make sure they know it. In my Texas CCL class we didn't talk about the legalities at all except for one time one of the students asked if it's OK to shoot when the police break in in the middle of the night without announcing themselves. (To which the instructor said it's probably not legal, but that he personally would do it anyway.)

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Sat Sep 14, 2019 9:53 am
by VodoundaVinci
FWIW I think Illinois 16 hour training and a 30 round proficiency is way better than most but could be improved. Mostly in the proficiency department - I'd like to more training hours in actually drawing the weapon from concealment and delivering accurate fire. We had an excellent trainer who gave us an hour of drawing from concealment training and it showed that 90% of the class could barely get it done.

VooDoo

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Tue Sep 17, 2019 4:55 pm
by DMac

VodoundaVinci wrote:FWIW I think Illinois 16 hour training and a 30 round proficiency is way better than most but could be improved. Mostly in the proficiency department - I'd like to more training hours in actually drawing the weapon from concealment and delivering accurate fire. We had an excellent trainer who gave us an hour of drawing from concealment training and it showed that 90% of the class could barely get it done.

VooDoo
I'm with you, but how would you write that requirement into legislation so it's not infringing on rights, moreso than the laws already do?



Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Tue Sep 17, 2019 7:53 pm
by NegativeApproach
VodoundaVinci wrote: Sat Sep 14, 2019 9:53 am FWIW I think Illinois 16 hour training and a 30 round proficiency is way better than most but could be improved. Mostly in the proficiency department - I'd like to more training hours in actually drawing the weapon from concealment and delivering accurate fire. We had an excellent trainer who gave us an hour of drawing from concealment training and it showed that 90% of the class could barely get it done.

VooDoo
One of the real problems is, that the majority of people in the state live in Chicago, where the city has blocked the existence of any ranges in decades.

I am all for more training, I am also for more accessibility for poor people and those who have to rely on public transit. Chicago has opposed adequate training by making it harder for people to train.

Re: Article: Who’s watching? More people licensed to carry guns in Illinois are using them, but oversight is still lacki

Posted: Wed Sep 18, 2019 9:49 am
by DMac
There aren't even any gunshops in Chicago