Page 6 of 13

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Tue Oct 03, 2017 9:34 pm
by lurker
ammonium nitrate and tannerite found in shooter's home, car
http://www.newsweek.com/las-vegas-polic ... hen-676272
building bombs? then why use guns? ran out of patience?
i think he's one of those folks who commits suicide while taking out others. suicide by cop with collateral damage. i think he expected, maybe wanted, to die.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 12:05 am
by senorgrand
lurker wrote:ammonium nitrate and tannerite found in shooter's home, car
http://www.newsweek.com/las-vegas-polic ... hen-676272
building bombs? then why use guns? ran out of patience?
i think he's one of those folks who commits suicide while taking out others. suicide by cop with collateral damage. i think he expected, maybe wanted, to die.
Most mass shooters want to go out in a blaze of infamy, which we are all too eager to provide.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 12:08 am
by AndyH
lurker wrote:ammonium nitrate and tannerite found in shooter's home, car
http://www.newsweek.com/las-vegas-polic ... hen-676272
building bombs? then why use guns? ran out of patience?
i think he's one of those folks who commits suicide while taking out others. suicide by cop with collateral damage. i think he expected, maybe wanted, to die.
Tannerite is ammonium nitrate and finely powdered aluminum. Ammonium nitrate is fertilizer. This is not relevant to the shooting, but is another 'scary' thing to report.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 12:20 am
by eelj
We are about to see cooperation between the parties, the gop will give into sweeping gun control and the dems will not only shut up about universal health care but throw ACA over the side, might even role up their sleeves and help build the wall. The corporate world will be so pleased.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 1:09 am
by highdesert
And from what we know, it appears that Paddock flew under the radar. No criminal record or anything that drew police attention.
The journey to the room at the end of the 32nd floor began at the switchboards of the Mandalay Bay Resort and Casino, a tropical fantasy in the Nevada desert. As the noises began, scores of confused guests pressed zero on their room phones almost all at once. The first callers asked about what sounded like a sustained burst of fireworks. Others wondered: Was it something else? The hotel operators realized that for callers on some floors, the popping was louder than for guests phoning in from others. Outside the hotel entrance, Las Vegas Metropolitan Police officers were pinned down along South Las Vegas Boulevard, searching for the origin of what they knew was a barrage of gunshots. Someone had been firing into a crowd of country music fans at a venue across the street. Muzzle flashes had been visible halfway up the hotel’s north tower — a clue that then disappeared.

“Haven’t seen any flashes,” an officer said over the radio at 10:22 p.m. Sunday. “There is a strobe light from one of those windows.” Steve Sisolak, chairman of the Clark County Commission, said it was clear that the shots were coming from the Mandalay Bay and that the flashes were coming from the windows facing the Strip, but that was about all: “They knew he was up there, and they didn’t know where.” Almost exactly an hour after those observations, a SWAT team burst into Stephen Paddock’s room and found the 64-year-old retired accountant dead; he had shot himself in the mouth with a handgun after spraying the concert crowd with bullets, killing 58 people and wounding more than 500. The raid ended a search that drew on the geometry of Paddock’s frantic attack and the evidence gathered by the hotel’s operators, who narrowed down his location based on the calls coming from frightened guests.

Police believed at one point that there might have been as many as three attackers, then “confirmed” at least two. The volume of Paddock’s fire made implausible the idea that one man was behind it. But in the end it was just Paddock, his motive still a mystery, a man who had taken extraordinary steps to monitor the progress of the raid on his room — a raid he knew would be coming. Two people close to the investigation said Paddock set up remote video cameras, which streamed images through a tablet so he could see down the hall behind him as he fired into the audience below. Police found one camera on a room-service cart parked in the hallway awaiting pickup. Probably alerted by the images of police approaching his suite at the end of a long hallway, Paddock fired numerous rounds through his door, hitting a hotel security guard who was clearing guest rooms one by one. The guard, whose name has not been released, was wounded in the leg by shrapnel kicked up from a ricocheting bullet, which did not hit him directly. The police radio crackled soon after: “Mandalay security says shooter is on 32nd floor, they have security officer on that floor who was shot.”

Questions since the shooting, the worst in modern U.S. history, have focused in part on the adequacy of hotel security. Paddock managed over several days to assemble an arsenal of 23 firearms in his room, many of them rifles, apparently bringing them up in 10 suitcases. Police and hotel security took more than an hour to find Paddock after he began firing. But there is much about this city’s confectionery skyline that appears designed specifically for someone who does not want to be found. The sheer scope of the Strip’s most popular hotels is chief among those features. With three wings and more than 3,200 rooms, the Mandalay Bay stands as a primary example of the city’s architecture of anonymity, the relatively tiny black holes Paddock punched through the reflective gold-glass facade evidence of the security staff’s needle-in-a-haystack endeavor. The search for his room began amid 11 minutes of sustained volleys of gunfire that scattered the 22,000 people at the Route 91 Harvest festival in an open-air concert ground across the street from the 40-story-plus Mandalay Bay. “We need to stop the shooter!” an officer said over the radio just after 10:17 p.m. “He’s firing right over our heads!”

Inside his room on the 32nd floor, Sonny Morgan, in town from Georgia for a conference, dozed in front of the “Sunday Night Football” game. “I woke up to the sounds of gunshots,” Morgan recalled in an interview with WXIA-TV in Atlanta. “Initially, I had kind of thought that it may have been some fireworks . . . and then it just kept going and going and going.” He called reception and was told to barricade himself inside his room. Then, after the furious initial barrage, the shooter paused. For about three minutes, Paddock stopped firing, leaving officers who were trying to track the trajectory of the shooting with little to go on. An officer commented just after 10:20 p.m., “Been a while since we heard shots.” A little more than a minute later, Paddock opened up again. “We are taking fire here!” one officer said, according to the radio transcript. “Advise officers do not go up on the boulevard.” One officer spotted what he described as a “strobe light” coming from midway up the hotel’s north tower.

At the time, Mandalay hotel security and the Las Vegas police were sorting through officer observations about the trajectory of the shots and what they were learning from the guest calls coming into the call center. Police officials say they concluded that the shooter was firing from a room between the 29th and 32nd floors. Security guards and police officers began clearing those floors, believing at the time that as many as three shooters might have been involved. At about 10:27 p.m., as officers outside began setting up a medical triage center at the nearby Tropicana Hotel amid continuing gunfire, the Mandalay security officer made his way down the hall on the 32nd floor toward the room at the end. Paddock, according to investigators and the radio transcript, gave himself away by firing through the door, but police were still convinced he was not alone. “Have confirmed that there are two shooters with fully automated weapons,” an officer said, according to the transcript, about a minute after the hotel guard was wounded.

From that moment on, though, the room at the end of the hall went quiet. On the Strip outside, police officers were securing their patrol cars after reports that private citizens had been grabbing shotguns from them for protection. Reports of shots fired at hotels north of the Mandalay — at the Luxor next door, at the Bellagio a mile up, at several others — commanded police attention. A man dressed in fatigues was tracked to an RV outside the Tropicana, and police moved in with shotguns. The reports of gunfire in other hotels proved unfounded, the man in fatigues a harmless distraction. Inside the hotel, the police moved toward Paddock, who had stopped firing. “Moving up to the 32nd floor,” an officer said on the radio about a half-hour into the attack. A minute later, from another officer, “Can confirm that there is no gunfire?” “We’ve been here for the past [unclear] minutes and haven’t heard gunshots for oh, probably 15 minutes,” came the response. Two minutes later: “We are covering the stairwell on 32.”

For the next half-hour, the SWAT team prepared for the raid. Morgan, the conference attendee, recalled in his interview with the Atlanta TV station, “I could hear the police making their way up the hallway, and they were basically breaking down the doors — opening the doors aggressively. “Six or seven SWAT guys came in and just made sure that I wasn’t a bad person — that I was doing what I was supposed to be doing,” he said. “They ushered us out and told us to run as far and as fast as we could to get away.” At about 11:25 p.m., the floor cleared except for the room at the end of the hall, a senior officer announced over the radio: “We are gonna set off outside the suspect’s door. We are gonna pop this and see if we get any kind of response from this guy.” “SWAT has explosive breach,” the dispatcher responded. “All units move back.” The raid did not last long. SWAT team members found Paddock on the floor, blood spilling from his mouth and pooling around his head.

Video from the hallway shows a room-service cart, probably the one in which Paddock placed a camera. Briefing reporters here Tuesday, Sheriff Joe Lombardo said room service did come to Paddock’s room. But he did not disclose at what time. Lombardo praised the hotel security response, saying, “We would not have engaged this individual in the time lapse that we did without their assistance.” “Were it not for the men and women of the police department and the security at Mandalay Bay to help triangulate that movement and get to the 32nd floor, the casualty toll would not be 59 people but in the hundreds,” Sisolak, the Clark County commissioner, said. “They saved hundreds of lives by their actions to find that room on the 32nd floor.” Devlin Barrett and Ann Gerhart in Washington contributed to this report.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national ... story.html

The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives said 47 weapons had been recovered from the hotel room, Paddock's residences in Mesquite and Verdi, Nevada. Paddock had devices attached to 12 weapons that enable semiautomatic rifles to mimic fully automatic gunfire, ATF special agent in charge Jill Schneider confirmed. The little-known devices, called "bump stocks," have been around for less than a decade, and Schneider said officials had determined they were legal.

The device basically replaces the gun's shoulder rest with a "support step" that covers the trigger opening. By holding the pistol grip with one hand and pushing forward on the barrel with the other, the shooter's finger comes in contact with the trigger. The recoil causes the gun to buck back and forth, "bumping" the trigger. Technically, that means the finger is pulling the trigger for each round fired, keeping the weapon a legal semi-automatic.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/las-vegas- ... ve-update/

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 2:27 am
by SilasSoule
Article claims Democratic leadership will seek to tighten gun laws but avoid firearm bans.

"Democrats are under pressure from a resurgent left that wants tough gun control legislation in the wake of the deadliest mass shooting in U.S. history. [...not targeting indigenous Americans.]

But Democratic leaders want to focus on more modest goals on gun control that are deliverable, such as expanded background checks and closing loopholes.

Hanging over everything is the 2018 midterm elections, when Senate Democrats will be defending 10 seats in states won by President Trump.

Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), a rising star who is eyeing a possible White House bid in 2020, is taking the lead on expanding background checks, which has widespread public support.

He and Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (N.Y.) are less gung-ho about pushing votes to restrict military-style rifles and high-capacity ammunition magazines, proposals Democrats pushed in 2013 after the mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School, and which failed by big margins.

“In general we have to be careful not to whipsaw our policy agenda back and forth based on the details of the last mass shooting. That’s why I think it’s important to constantly be talking about the one policy change that would save the most lives: background checks,” said Murphy."

http://thehill.com/homenews/senate/3537 ... un-control

Turns out Paddock was also a former government employee. “He had done some government work during his career, as a letter carrier for the Postal Service, an agent for the Internal Revenue Service and an auditor for the federal government’s Defense Contract Audit Agency in the late 1970s and 1980s.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/pos ... -shooting/

And at one time worked for a military contractor. "Paddock had worked for a predecessor company of Lockheed Martin, the giant defense contractor that builds planes." https://finance.yahoo.com/news/know-ste ... 07198.html

So I have an unrelated question. Why did this guy haul all those guns (23) up to his room? Really, how many did he think he needed? I understand owning lots of guns - some people are collectors, but even if you are Rambo you can only shoot two at a time. Sorry to sound like I'm wearing a tinfoil hat (again) but was this supposed to make a point about how easy it is to buy a huge arsenal of guns or something? Was he going to see how it felt to shoot defenseless people with different weapons?

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 5:58 am
by Antiquus
10 bumpfire mechanisms should be a huge warning. These things should at least have hightened tracking and reporting, 10 of them in any place should deserve some scrutiny. The damn manufacturers at least should keep track.

Don't know yet how this will shake out, but expect "thoughts and prayers" and then business as usual.

However the sight of all those cowboy hats crouching helpless while they got slaughtered was one I never expected to see, and something may have changed in America.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 7:04 am
by KlownKannon
Antiquus wrote:However the sight of all those cowboy hats crouching helpless while they got slaughtered was one I never expected to see, and something may have changed in America.
I wish I could share your optimism but the slaughter of school children didn't do it....we're kind of a fucked up culture from top to bottom.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 8:46 am
by lurker
KlownKannon wrote:we're kind of a fucked up culture from top to bottom.
man was not designed by nature to live in such numbers, in such close proximity. two solutions come to mind: thin us out some, or redesign people.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 9:07 am
by Wino
KlownKannon wrote:
Antiquus wrote:However the sight of all those cowboy hats crouching helpless while they got slaughtered was one I never expected to see, and something may have changed in America.
I wish I could share your optimism but the slaughter of school children didn't do it....we're kind of a fucked up culture from top to bottom.
Sandy Creek and nothing of consequence. I don't expect anything concrete after Las Vegas, either. Eventually, citizens (pro, anti and indifferent) will get their fill of the carnage and strong laws, registration and bans will come down no matter which party is in power. Just a matter of time - probably 20-50 years and we'll see it coming (those still alive), so rest easy for near future. This provided current doofus POTUS doesn't get us all nuked before.

What I've always feared is taxing ammo like they've done tobacco - making it a rich man's sport - rather than gun bans. Won't accomplish anything, but will make some feel, incorrectly, they have made a dent in crime and murder. I can see requiring ID / registration on ammo purchases; banning bump stocks, trigger gats, magazines; and eventually handgun laws being applied to rifles / long guns; but no bans, just restrictions, sooner rather than later. All because insane losers with guns doing stupid shit and killing innocent people for no legit reason.

Please, anyone, spare me the normal bull shit comparing auto accidents, drug over doses, medical errors, knife/machete, etal causing more deaths than guns cause there is no correlation. What happened in Vegas, Sandy Hook, etc horror has no relationship to other methods of death.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 9:27 am
by SailDesign
SilasSoule wrote:<huge snip-de-dip>

So I have an unrelated question. Why did this guy haul all those guns (23) up to his room? Really, how many did he think he needed? I understand owning lots of guns - some people are collectors, but even if you are Rambo you can only shoot two at a time. Sorry to sound like I'm wearing a tinfoil hat (again) but was this supposed to make a point about how easy it is to buy a huge arsenal of guns or something? Was he going to see how it felt to shoot defenseless people with different weapons?
I would hazard a guess that he expected jams at some point, so wanted a few "spares" - but that is a free opinion and you DO get what you pay for...

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 9:50 am
by CDFingers
Anti-gun liberals are using "blood-on-their-hands" rhetoric to attack Republicans and the NRA.

Pro-gun conservatives are mocking gun-control proposals as unworkable or irrelevant.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/commentary ... picks=true

That pretty much says it all: when one's constitution allows wide spread gun ownership--despite Ninth and Tenth Amendment local restrictions--and the People are by nature tribal, aggressive, and violent, you get this kind of thing.

Image


Full disclosure on edit: I'm an Old White Guy (OWG).

While I think it best for many people to carry concealed so from time to time a bad guy can get shot, the current social conditions in our country select in favor of idiots going postal.

The solution to a continually-decreasing number of incidents like this lies in increasing the health of our society in all ways.

But until profit can be made doing that, we're pretty much screwn.

CDFingers

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 10:07 am
by senorgrand
Every mass shooter in American history has gotten exactly what he wanted...fame.


Until that equation is disrupted, expect more of the same.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 10:12 am
by whitey
Everybody here cool with a permanent ban on bump fire stocks or is that gonna hurt your delicate sensibilities? FWIW I’m cool with registration and banning bump fire stocks. If that offends you more than the mass slaughter of innocents, go fuck yourselves. This one hit close to home. My best man at my wedding, his wife was there with her friends enjoying the night. Thankfully she made it out unscathed, many didn’t. This country has a deadly fanaticism with guns that borders on insane, definitely absurd.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 10:22 am
by CDFingers
whitey wrote:Everybody here cool with a permanent ban on bump fire stocks or is that gonna hurt your delicate sensibilities? FWIW I’m cool with registration and banning bump fire stocks. If that offends you more than the mass slaughter of innocents, go fuck yourselves. This one hit close to home. My best man at my wedding, his wife was there with her friends enjoying the night. Thankfully she made it out unscathed, many didn’t. This country has a deadly fanaticism with guns that borders on insane, definitely absurd.
While i'm totally OK with registration and back ground checks, I'm not strongly enamored of a ban on anything. it's true that no one "needs" a bump fire stock. The "needs" argument is specious and should be suspect, as it calls up the slippery slope.

I don't think we know enough about this shooter to know whether registration would have done anything to prevent. Certainly if bump fire stocks were impossible to get, it would have been tougher to fire so many rounds.

I am glad that your friends came home safely.

The more I read about this incident, the more I'm convinced it was pre planned evil by a madman who used our freedoms against us.

I'm at a loss on how to prevent this in the future. I'm sad it happened. If it turns out he had help and was not "just" a lone wolf, I'm gonna be hella pissed.

CDFingers

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:02 am
by highdesert
This is from the Las Vegas Review-Journal the major LV newspaper, now owned by the big Rep donor, Sheldon Adelson. There was housekeeping and room service staff in that suite. "See something, say something."
The deadliest shooting in U.S. history will force the nation’s hotel industry to rethink security procedures, but there may be little new they can do now to prevent such events, experts say. Hotels can’t install metal detectors or other elements deemed intrusive without damaging the whole concept of hospitality that is at the heart of their business, academics said Monday. Hotel operators will have to rely even more on the eyes and ears of regular employees such as housekeeping staff and front desk workers to detect and report unusual behavior.

“No matter what we do, there are always going to be security issues. The responsibility has to be on every level and not just security personnel. Everyone should be flagging odd behavior,’’ said Mehmet Erdem, a hospitality professor at the University of Nevada Las Vegas. Stephen Paddock, a 64-year old Nevada resident, sneaked 16 rifles and one handgun into his room at Mandalay Bay, where he checked in on Thursday. Paddock used them to open fire on a crowd attending a country music concert from his room on the 32nd floor around 10 p.m. Sunday. Police said 59 people are dead. MGM Resorts International, which owns Mandalay Bay, declined comment Monday, pending an ongoing investigation, on how Paddock got such an arsenal into his room without being detected by security or housekeeping. While casinos and hotels do not permit people to walk through their private property with concealed or unconcealed weapons, there is little to stop them from letting guests enter with guns hidden in bags.

Sunday’s massacre tarnished the Strip’s reputation as one of the nation’s safest streets. Casinos along famed Las Vegas Boulevard have hundreds of surveillance cameras in public places, including in front of the properties and in parking lots. Casinos have their own private security staff roaming the floors. Metro has a noticeable presence along the Strip as well. Paddock traveled by car to Las Vegas from Mesquite, a town about a 90-minute ride away, presumably with the guns in his car. “At all of our properties, we have pretty robust security. In light of what happened, we will review those measures and heighten them as necessary,’’ said David Strow, a spokesman for Boyd Gaming Corp., which has casinos in downtown Las Vegas. Casinos will likely add more security personnel in the aftermath of the massacre, said Michael McCall, a professor at Michigan State University’s School of Hospitality. “Security being present to the extent that they are noticeable would be a disincentive’’ to criminals, said McCall. McCall agreed with Erdem that metal detectors would not be a viable solution as it would hurt the guest experience. People will not want to stand in long lines like they do at airport security posts.

“Vacationers want to relax, they don’t want to be reminded of the dangers in the world,’’ said McCall. Hotels will need to beef up their training programs so that all employees, and not just security personnel, can learn to detect suspicious behavior, said Erdem. Strip casinos could consult with airlines on how they spot suspicious behavior, he said. Odd behavior in isolation can often be explained away, but if several employees notice unusual behavior and report it to a central location, hotels can respond before tragedy happens, Erdem said. McCall said the hotel industry will likely learn “a lot of lessons” from this case and the study of the surveillance tapes. “This is kind of a wake-up call to the hotel industry. It will change people’s thoughts about hotel security,’’ he said.
https://www.reviewjournal.com/local/the ... -security/

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:04 am
by DispositionMatrix
whitey wrote:Everybody here cool with a permanent ban on bump fire stocks or is that gonna hurt your delicate sensibilities? FWIW I’m cool with registration and banning bump fire stocks. If that offends you more than the mass slaughter of innocents, go fuck yourselves. This one hit close to home. My best man at my wedding, his wife was there with her friends enjoying the night. Thankfully she made it out unscathed, many didn’t. This country has a deadly fanaticism with guns that borders on insane, definitely absurd.
I would not see any connection between my ownership of a Slide Fire and someone else murdering a bunch of people. That said, I have little doubt bump fire stocks are going to be banned since that will make people feel good. No idea what "a deadly fanaticism with guns" is supposed to be, but since gun ownership is not required in this country you're free to give yours up out of guilt over murders you had no hand in perpetrating.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:11 am
by CDFingers
The Liberal Redneck:



CDFingers

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:14 am
by TrueTexan
CDFingers wrote:
whitey wrote:Everybody here cool with a permanent ban on bump fire stocks or is that gonna hurt your delicate sensibilities? FWIW I’m cool with registration and banning bump fire stocks. If that offends you more than the mass slaughter of innocents, go fuck yourselves. This one hit close to home. My best man at my wedding, his wife was there with her friends enjoying the night. Thankfully she made it out unscathed, many didn’t. This country has a deadly fanaticism with guns that borders on insane, definitely absurd.
While i'm totally OK with registration and back ground checks, I'm not strongly enamored of a ban on anything. it's true that no one "needs" a bump fire stock. The "needs" argument is specious and should be suspect, as it calls up the slippery slope.

I don't think we know enough about this shooter to know whether registration would have done anything to prevent. Certainly if bump fire stocks were impossible to get, it would have been tougher to fire so many rounds.

I am glad that your friends came home safely.

The more I read about this incident, the more I'm convinced it was pre planned evil by a madman who used our freedoms against us.

I'm at a loss on how to prevent this in the future. I'm sad it happened. If it turns out he had help and was not "just" a lone wolf, I'm gonna be hella pissed.

CDFingers
How about, not banning the bump fire stocks or other devices that effectively give you full automatic fire, but put them in the same class as the full automatic weapons as for registration, movement notification and tax stamp. Also stiffer penalties for violating the laws on having an unregistered device or automatic weapon.

To pay for the government paper trail I would even see an annual registration fee on the tax stamp, just like your car tags. If you can afford to shoot automatic weapons even using the Bump Fire then you can afford the annual tax stamp.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:29 am
by DispositionMatrix
TrueTexan wrote:How about, not banning the bump fire stocks or other devices that effectively give you full automatic fire, but put them in the same class as the full automatic weapons as for registration, movement notification and tax stamp. Also stiffer penalties for violating the laws on having an unregistered device or automatic weapon.
The shooter, who had holed up specifically to commit mass murder and knew he would not be leaving alive, definitely would have rethought his actions had there been stiffer penalties for possessing unregistered devices.
TrueTexan wrote:To pay for the government paper trail I would even see an annual registration fee on the tax stamp, just like your car tags. If you can afford to shoot automatic weapons even using the Bump Fire then you can afford the annual tax stamp.
I don't think NFA items should be the domain of the rich and would be loath to encourage thinking that suggests wealth makes one a more responsible, more deserving gun owner.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:35 am
by senorgrand
I'm cool with bump-fire stocks going to tax stamp status. But since gun owners are asked by prohibitionists to "compromise" on new gun laws, what thing will they give up in return?

BTW, I'm guessing there is very little in a bumpfire stock that couldn't be produced with a 3d printer and a trip to the hardware store and if you have skills, just the latter.

But the same could be said of suppressors...

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:37 am
by p0lyhuman
None of what has been suggested here regarding the banning of various non-firearm parts, which are even easier to manufacture than firearms, would do anything to prevent another incident like this if someone were determined.

Did you all just discover that these devices exist? They have been sold for more than a decade and they have not been showing up at crime scenes as far as I know.

Determined mass murderers with resources and no criminal record are exactly who will be willing to overcome whatever barriers are put up. I don't know what the answer is but trying to wipe a piece of plastic out of existence probably isn't it.

Edit: Senorgrand you bring up the relevant political/strategic issues, thank you.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:50 am
by DispositionMatrix
senorgrand wrote:But since gun owners are asked by prohibitionists to "compromise" on new gun laws, what thing will they give up in return?
Gun prohibitionists are definitely going to take something, but I'm sure they are giving serious thought to what they're going to give in return and have simply forgotten to mention it.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 11:59 am
by highdesert
TrueTexan wrote:
CDFingers wrote:
whitey wrote:Everybody here cool with a permanent ban on bump fire stocks or is that gonna hurt your delicate sensibilities? FWIW I’m cool with registration and banning bump fire stocks. If that offends you more than the mass slaughter of innocents, go fuck yourselves. This one hit close to home. My best man at my wedding, his wife was there with her friends enjoying the night. Thankfully she made it out unscathed, many didn’t. This country has a deadly fanaticism with guns that borders on insane, definitely absurd.
While i'm totally OK with registration and back ground checks, I'm not strongly enamored of a ban on anything. it's true that no one "needs" a bump fire stock. The "needs" argument is specious and should be suspect, as it calls up the slippery slope.

I don't think we know enough about this shooter to know whether registration would have done anything to prevent. Certainly if bump fire stocks were impossible to get, it would have been tougher to fire so many rounds.

I am glad that your friends came home safely.

The more I read about this incident, the more I'm convinced it was pre planned evil by a madman who used our freedoms against us.

I'm at a loss on how to prevent this in the future. I'm sad it happened. If it turns out he had help and was not "just" a lone wolf, I'm gonna be hella pissed.

CDFingers
How about, not banning the bump fire stocks or other devices that effectively give you full automatic fire, but put them in the same class as the full automatic weapons as for registration, movement notification and tax stamp. Also stiffer penalties for violating the laws on having an unregistered device or automatic weapon.

To pay for the government paper trail I would even see an annual registration fee on the tax stamp, just like your car tags. If you can afford to shoot automatic weapons even using the Bump Fire then you can afford the annual tax stamp.
I think that registering bump stocks would be more pallitable to gun groups.

Trae Crowder is right, this shooting is different because an old white guy did it and it was at a country-western event. There were nine less casualties in last years Pulse Nightclub shooting, but the shooter was Arab, a terrorist and he was killing gays and lesbians so it was easier for many to dismiss.

Re: At Least 50 Dead in Las Vegas Shooting, Full Automatic F

Posted: Wed Oct 04, 2017 12:05 pm
by shinzen
It comes down to the same question we've asked time and time again here. "Okay. You've banned X. Now what?" Another event happens. "Now you've banned Y. Now what?" Another event happens ad nauseum.

Personally, I don't give two shits about bump fire stocks either. Tax stamp them? Sure. Whatever. Might be hard to accomplish since they're not required to have a serial number, so it would be 100% on the people that already own them, so good luck getting that to happen. If anything, it would likely be like the 1986 act making the ongoing manufacture of them illegal.

But then what? Background checks would not have made one bit of difference for this event. Not one bit. It's the same story for every mass shooting- screams for universal background checks, when the people acquired them legally in the first place. Restrictions on "assault weapons" when we know that a Mini-14 is no different in function from an AR-15.

The 538 article does give me some hope that some of the alternatives we have discussed and proposed may actually gain some traction. Treating each type of death the same will result in shitty outcomes, and rather than asking why, will push for more "fixes" that won't work.