Some history lessons that we really need to examine

1
Three specific but seldom taught history lesson that are extremely relevant today that need to be publicly reviewed and broadly disseminated are the 1900 Bubonic Plague in San Fransisco where local state and federal all the way to Governor and Presidential levels agreed and conspired to suppress all the data and study and limit all efforts the infection to keep business running and make sure there was no interruption of the availability of domestic servants; the "Troubles in Northern Ireland and the "Zoot Suit" WWII riots.

All three are examples of what we are very likely to see over the next few years, denial of science and evidence that might have a negative short term impact on wealth, just how fast a small disaffected percentage of a population can lead to open warfare and the tacit approval of law enforcement and military to actively suppress a minority community.
To be vintage it must be older than me!
The next gun I buy will be the next to last gun I ever buy. PROMISE!
jim

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

4
Hey! They are still teaching school kids that the Pilgrims bravely came to Plymouth Rock for religious freedom. Which is bullshit. They HAD religious freedom in Holland, but it was too liberal for them! Less than 70 years after they landed they were hanging each other as witches in order to grab each other's wealth.
"Even if the bee could explain to the fly why pollen is better than shit, the fly could never understand."

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

5
YankeeTarheel wrote: Fri Sep 29, 2023 6:39 pm Hey! They are still teaching school kids that the Pilgrims bravely came to Plymouth Rock for religious freedom. Which is bullshit. They HAD religious freedom in Holland, but it was too liberal for them! Less than 70 years after they landed they were hanging each other as witches in order to grab each other's wealth.
Yep, and oppressing the first arrivals at every chance. What else is new.
Image
Image

"Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated!" Loquacious of many. Texas Chapter Chief Cat Herder.

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

8
The immediate problem is that it's highly possible that neither Republicans or Democrats will garner 270 Electoral votes in 2024 and there is no indication the House would not support Trump or the SCOTUS intervene to prevent a House elected Trump Presidency or that any other possible outcome would be acceptable to the MGA loyalists.

It is exactly why I selected those three specific examples.

We have a large Wealth Power faction that has no trouble denying reality or evidence or science if those lines are inconvenient just as California and the major port at San Francisco in 1900 and a ready already selected host of THEMS to direct all the evil towards and an already well armed disaffected and organized domestic Freedom Fighter Militia and that just don't look like a pleasant scenario.

Plus we have a 13 month window of opportunity to make changes but absolutely no consensus, model, method, mechanism, process or procedure that offers an realistic likelihood of success.

The bright news is that Japan, China, Europe, Vietnam and even the former Soviet vassal states somehow did survive pretty much total destruction and collapse though the pain and costs and suffering were great.
Last edited by sig230 on Sat Sep 30, 2023 9:24 pm, edited 1 time in total.
To be vintage it must be older than me!
The next gun I buy will be the next to last gun I ever buy. PROMISE!
jim

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

9
Eris wrote: Fri Sep 29, 2023 7:54 pm I've never heard about this plague thing before.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Franc ... _1900-1904

Interesting. It broke out in Chinatown. When there was a second outbreak city wide in 1908 the response was swift. I have to wonder how racism played into the original response.
You need to look a few months further back because it also happened in Hawaii and there the result was simply that all of China Town was burned down. Remember at the time Chinese were not and could not be citizens, own property, have access to the cities hospitals. The 1908 outbreak in SF was actually a continuation of the spread mask by the intentional misdiagnose of deaths and the believe that WHITES were immune to the plague and it was an Asian disease.

Anyone remember a recent pandemic and an assignment of blame to ...
To be vintage it must be older than me!
The next gun I buy will be the next to last gun I ever buy. PROMISE!
jim

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

12
When I was in High School the average person didn't know we, the USA, had concentration camps in WWII and we put our own citizens in them because their ancestors or their parents were born in Japan. We did not do it to German or Italian citizens, just Japanese. Gov. Earl Warren, the same who was Chief Justice, requested it and FDR agreed.
"Even if the bee could explain to the fly why pollen is better than shit, the fly could never understand."

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

13
YankeeTarheel wrote: Fri Sep 29, 2023 11:10 pm When I was in High School the average person didn't know we, the USA, had concentration camps in WWII and we put our own citizens in them because their ancestors or their parents were born in Japan. We did not do it to German or Italian citizens, just Japanese. Gov. Earl Warren, the same who was Chief Justice, requested it and FDR agreed.
My step mother's parents were in the camps here. My step father had family that were in the camps over there. It blows my mind many people don't believe either.

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

14
featureless wrote: Sat Sep 30, 2023 1:02 am
YankeeTarheel wrote: Fri Sep 29, 2023 11:10 pm When I was in High School the average person didn't know we, the USA, had concentration camps in WWII and we put our own citizens in them because their ancestors or their parents were born in Japan. We did not do it to German or Italian citizens, just Japanese. Gov. Earl Warren, the same who was Chief Justice, requested it and FDR agreed.
My step mother's parents were in the camps here. My step father had family that were in the camps over there. It blows my mind many people don't believe either.
We’ve been pretty good with propaganda and sanitizing our history to reflect the image we wanted to see of ourselves. It went along with all the destiny crap that was needed to build and conquer a continent later to extend power to the southern hemisphere and beyond across the seas, Monroe Doctrine and all. Unfortunately we still do it, we just call it our national interest, even though it’s really our corporation’s interest and dominance that’s being protected. The issues of immigration we have now are rooted in our past sins, our interference, our projection of power and the propaganda we have projected to others about us. Admitting mistakes and sins is hard when ego is involved. Y’all no doubt recall in recent years the separation of children from their parents and their detainment in camps. It’s not so different from our past sins, it’s just a matter of scale. With the first arrivals it was reservations, then internment camps for those Japanese ancestry as noted and there’s always more subtle ways in recent years. History really does repeat itself especially when we refuse to acknowledge it. On the other hand those who have learned history repeat it for the same reason, power and wealth. Unfortunately it’s always the poor and unprivileged that pay here and abroad. Perhaps someday we can do good and really strive for the ideals we put on paper. One can hope.
Image
Image

"Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated!" Loquacious of many. Texas Chapter Chief Cat Herder.

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

15
sikacz wrote: Sat Sep 30, 2023 4:37 am
featureless wrote: Sat Sep 30, 2023 1:02 am
YankeeTarheel wrote: Fri Sep 29, 2023 11:10 pm When I was in High School the average person didn't know we, the USA, had concentration camps in WWII and we put our own citizens in them because their ancestors or their parents were born in Japan. We did not do it to German or Italian citizens, just Japanese. Gov. Earl Warren, the same who was Chief Justice, requested it and FDR agreed.
My step mother's parents were in the camps here. My step father had family that were in the camps over there. It blows my mind many people don't believe either.
We’ve been pretty good with propaganda and sanitizing our history to reflect the image we wanted to see of ourselves. It went along with all the destiny crap that was needed to build and conquer a continent later to extend power to the southern hemisphere and beyond across the seas, Monroe Doctrine and all. Unfortunately we still do it, we just call it our national interest, even though it’s really our corporation’s interest and dominance that’s being protected. The issues of immigration we have now are rooted in our past sins, our interference, our projection of power and the propaganda we have projected to others about us. Admitting mistakes and sins is hard when ego is involved. Y’all no doubt recall in recent years the separation of children from their parents and their detainment in camps. It’s not so different from our past sins, it’s just a matter of scale. With the first arrivals it was reservations, then internment camps for those Japanese ancestry as noted and there’s always more subtle ways in recent years. History really does repeat itself especially when we refuse to acknowledge it. On the other hand those who have learned history repeat it for the same reason, power and wealth. Unfortunately it’s always the poor and unprivileged that pay here and abroad. Perhaps someday we can do good and really strive for the ideals we put on paper. One can hope.
Will Rogers said that the rich ALWAYS get all the money and trickle-down doesn't happen. But if you give $$$ to the poor people it will STILL end up in the wealthy's hands, but at least it passed through the poor man's hands on the way. He said this just after FDR was elected.
"Even if the bee could explain to the fly why pollen is better than shit, the fly could never understand."

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

16
Much has improved in Northern Ireland, but "The Troubles" are not over. Factions of the IRA and Ulster Volunteer forces still exist. In spite of the Good Friday Accords, the province doesn't have a functioning government because the political parties can't agree, so it's ruled from London. The origins go back centuries when James VI of Scotland because James I of England and the crowns were united. He settled loyal Scots in Ulster (Northern Ireland) and they became wealthy landlords and the divisions and discrimination started.

During WWII the Republic of Ireland was neutral even though many Irish lads joined the British Army. Churchill tried to entice the Irish prime minister DeValera into abandoning neutrality and in return he would give the Republic the 6 northern counties (Ulster/Northern Ireland). DeValera refused, he didn't want the political and religious divisions. And the Island of Ireland is still divided.
"Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but not their own facts." - Daniel Patrick Moynihan

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

17
As long a military aggression benefits the few wealthy profiteers who themselves never fight, we will continue to see wars. Vietnam keeps getting brought up. Easily we can identify those companies and networks who made pots of money but neither went themselves nor sent their kids. It keeps happening while people rant at the wrong things.

CDFingers
Can't talk to you without talking to me. We're guilty of the same old things.
Thinking a lot about less and less, and forgetting the love we bring

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

19
CDFingers wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 9:58 am As long a military aggression benefits the few wealthy profiteers who themselves never fight, we will continue to see wars. Vietnam keeps getting brought up. Easily we can identify those companies and networks who made pots of money but neither went themselves nor sent their kids. It keeps happening while people rant at the wrong things.

CDFingers
We have seen this for decades. A great example is Kellogg Brown & Root., AKA., KBR. During the time of our southeast asian fiasco known as Vietnam War almost all major bases the US used were built by KBR. Same goes for the Iraq War and Afghanistan. Back before and during the Vietnam War Herman Brown of KBR would sit in his suite in Houston's best hotel. This is where LBJ had been meeting with him for years as a senator and later as the President. It was well known that Brown was a major contributor to LBJ's campaign and the Democratic party along with being a major player in Texas politics.

Interesting side note. In 1954 the battle of Điện Biên Phủ was taking place in French Indo China AKA Vietnam. French President Charles de Gaulle asked the US government for help in relieving the French forces there. The US defense dept. had the Air force develop a plan that would have the B-36 Bombers to bomb the Viet Minh forces and allow the French to continue the war. The plan was called Operation Turkey Buzzard. My dad was part of the plan while he was stationed at Carswell AFB with the B-36s and had been briefed into the plan. All looked good to go, till LBJ speaking in the US Senate said, "Our Boys will not go and fight or get involved in a war in southeast Asia. Since he was the Senate Majority Leader and his good friend and fellow Texan, Sam Rayburn, was the speaker of the House. That killed the plans. deGaulle never forgave LBJ for that action. Had Kennedy/LBJ later followed that advice, just think how many US lives would still be with us today.
Facts do not cease to exist because they are ignored.-Huxley
"We can have democracy in this country, or we can have great wealth concentrated in the hands of a few, but we can't have both." ~ Louis Brandeis,

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

20
TrueTexan wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 11:23 am
CDFingers wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 9:58 am As long a military aggression benefits the few wealthy profiteers who themselves never fight, we will continue to see wars. Vietnam keeps getting brought up. Easily we can identify those companies and networks who made pots of money but neither went themselves nor sent their kids. It keeps happening while people rant at the wrong things.

CDFingers
We have seen this for decades. A great example is Kellogg Brown & Root., AKA., KBR. During the time of our southeast asian fiasco known as Vietnam War almost all major bases the US used were built by KBR. Same goes for the Iraq War and Afghanistan. Back before and during the Vietnam War Herman Brown of KBR would sit in his suite in Houston's best hotel. This is where LBJ had been meeting with him for years as a senator and later as the President. It was well known that Brown was a major contributor to LBJ's campaign and the Democratic party along with being a major player in Texas politics.

Interesting side note. In 1954 the battle of Điện Biên Phủ was taking place in French Indo China AKA Vietnam. French President Charles de Gaulle asked the US government for help in relieving the French forces there. The US defense dept. had the Air force develop a plan that would have the B-36 Bombers to bomb the Viet Minh forces and allow the French to continue the war. The plan was called Operation Turkey Buzzard. My dad was part of the plan while he was stationed at Carswell AFB with the B-36s and had been briefed into the plan. All looked good to go, till LBJ speaking in the US Senate said, "Our Boys will not go and fight or get involved in a war in southeast Asia. Since he was the Senate Majority Leader and his good friend and fellow Texan, Sam Rayburn, was the speaker of the House. That killed the plans. deGaulle never forgave LBJ for that action. Had Kennedy/LBJ later followed that advice, just think how many US lives would still be with us today.
You've omitted some key facts and I disagree with your analysis. Let's start with the fact that the French had no justification for trying to take back control of Vietnam. As they had been conquered by Japan's ally, Nazi Germany, they weren't there to defend Vietnam from the Japanese invasion. No, it was the Viet Minh, with some US support, that threw out the Japanese. Ho Chi Minh has a long history of good reasons not to trust the US. As a young lawyer, he tried to get an interview with racist Woodrow Wilson at the Paris Peace Conference about self-determination but Wilson refused to have anything to do with him. Ho's three major fears were invasion by Japan (obviously), invasion by China (a concern to this very day) and the French re-establishing control of his nation. With the US unwilling to aid him, and China too close, he turned to the USSR and embraced Socialism. But he was first and foremost a Vietnamese patriot. With the anti-Communist stupidity in the USA after the War, our government was too blind to see that an independent Vietnam would be a GIANT thorn in China's side, not recognizing that monolithic Communism didn't exist. The Soviets and the PRC HATED each other, and Vietnam hated China as well.

Lives would have been saved if Ho Chih Minh had been recognized as the leader of Vietnam instead of setting up the puppet governments in the South. Vietnam was NOT Korea, and still isn't. Vietnam could have been Asia's Yugoslavia, which was a HUGE thorn in Russia's side under Tito--and we quietly worked with him.
"Even if the bee could explain to the fly why pollen is better than shit, the fly could never understand."

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

21
YankeeTarheel wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 3:17 pm
TrueTexan wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 11:23 am
CDFingers wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 9:58 am As long a military aggression benefits the few wealthy profiteers who themselves never fight, we will continue to see wars. Vietnam keeps getting brought up. Easily we can identify those companies and networks who made pots of money but neither went themselves nor sent their kids. It keeps happening while people rant at the wrong things.

CDFingers
We have seen this for decades. A great example is Kellogg Brown & Root., AKA., KBR. During the time of our southeast asian fiasco known as Vietnam War almost all major bases the US used were built by KBR. Same goes for the Iraq War and Afghanistan. Back before and during the Vietnam War Herman Brown of KBR would sit in his suite in Houston's best hotel. This is where LBJ had been meeting with him for years as a senator and later as the President. It was well known that Brown was a major contributor to LBJ's campaign and the Democratic party along with being a major player in Texas politics.

Interesting side note. In 1954 the battle of Điện Biên Phủ was taking place in French Indo China AKA Vietnam. French President Charles de Gaulle asked the US government for help in relieving the French forces there. The US defense dept. had the Air force develop a plan that would have the B-36 Bombers to bomb the Viet Minh forces and allow the French to continue the war. The plan was called Operation Turkey Buzzard. My dad was part of the plan while he was stationed at Carswell AFB with the B-36s and had been briefed into the plan. All looked good to go, till LBJ speaking in the US Senate said, "Our Boys will not go and fight or get involved in a war in southeast Asia. Since he was the Senate Majority Leader and his good friend and fellow Texan, Sam Rayburn, was the speaker of the House. That killed the plans. deGaulle never forgave LBJ for that action. Had Kennedy/LBJ later followed that advice, just think how many US lives would still be with us today.
You've omitted some key facts and I disagree with your analysis. Let's start with the fact that the French had no justification for trying to take back control of Vietnam. As they had been conquered by Japan's ally, Nazi Germany, they weren't there to defend Vietnam from the Japanese invasion. No, it was the Viet Minh, with some US support, that threw out the Japanese. Ho Chi Minh has a long history of good reasons not to trust the US. As a young lawyer, he tried to get an interview with racist Woodrow Wilson at the Paris Peace Conference about self-determination but Wilson refused to have anything to do with him. Ho's three major fears were invasion by Japan (obviously), invasion by China (a concern to this very day) and the French re-establishing control of his nation. With the US unwilling to aid him, and China too close, he turned to the USSR and embraced Socialism. But he was first and foremost a Vietnamese patriot. With the anti-Communist stupidity in the USA after the War, our government was too blind to see that an independent Vietnam would be a GIANT thorn in China's side, not recognizing that monolithic Communism didn't exist. The Soviets and the PRC HATED each other, and Vietnam hated China as well.

Lives would have been saved if Ho Chih Minh had been recognized as the leader of Vietnam instead of setting up the puppet governments in the South. Vietnam was NOT Korea, and still isn't. Vietnam could have been Asia's Yugoslavia, which was a HUGE thorn in Russia's side under Tito--and we quietly worked with him.
You can cite pretty much the same tale when it comes to Cuba, Nicaragua, Columbia, Iraq, Iran, Syria, Lebanon ...

We have often been our own worst enemy.
To be vintage it must be older than me!
The next gun I buy will be the next to last gun I ever buy. PROMISE!
jim

Re: Some history lessons that we really need to examine

23
sig230 wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 3:24 pm
YankeeTarheel wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 3:17 pm
TrueTexan wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 11:23 am
CDFingers wrote: Sun Oct 01, 2023 9:58 am As long a military aggression benefits the few wealthy profiteers who themselves never fight, we will continue to see wars. Vietnam keeps getting brought up. Easily we can identify those companies and networks who made pots of money but neither went themselves nor sent their kids. It keeps happening while people rant at the wrong things.

CDFingers
We have seen this for decades. A great example is Kellogg Brown & Root., AKA., KBR. During the time of our southeast asian fiasco known as Vietnam War almost all major bases the US used were built by KBR. Same goes for the Iraq War and Afghanistan. Back before and during the Vietnam War Herman Brown of KBR would sit in his suite in Houston's best hotel. This is where LBJ had been meeting with him for years as a senator and later as the President. It was well known that Brown was a major contributor to LBJ's campaign and the Democratic party along with being a major player in Texas politics.

Interesting side note. In 1954 the battle of Điện Biên Phủ was taking place in French Indo China AKA Vietnam. French President Charles de Gaulle asked the US government for help in relieving the French forces there. The US defense dept. had the Air force develop a plan that would have the B-36 Bombers to bomb the Viet Minh forces and allow the French to continue the war. The plan was called Operation Turkey Buzzard. My dad was part of the plan while he was stationed at Carswell AFB with the B-36s and had been briefed into the plan. All looked good to go, till LBJ speaking in the US Senate said, "Our Boys will not go and fight or get involved in a war in southeast Asia. Since he was the Senate Majority Leader and his good friend and fellow Texan, Sam Rayburn, was the speaker of the House. That killed the plans. deGaulle never forgave LBJ for that action. Had Kennedy/LBJ later followed that advice, just think how many US lives would still be with us today.
You've omitted some key facts and I disagree with your analysis. Let's start with the fact that the French had no justification for trying to take back control of Vietnam. As they had been conquered by Japan's ally, Nazi Germany, they weren't there to defend Vietnam from the Japanese invasion. No, it was the Viet Minh, with some US support, that threw out the Japanese. Ho Chi Minh has a long history of good reasons not to trust the US. As a young lawyer, he tried to get an interview with racist Woodrow Wilson at the Paris Peace Conference about self-determination but Wilson refused to have anything to do with him. Ho's three major fears were invasion by Japan (obviously), invasion by China (a concern to this very day) and the French re-establishing control of his nation. With the US unwilling to aid him, and China too close, he turned to the USSR and embraced Socialism. But he was first and foremost a Vietnamese patriot. With the anti-Communist stupidity in the USA after the War, our government was too blind to see that an independent Vietnam would be a GIANT thorn in China's side, not recognizing that monolithic Communism didn't exist. The Soviets and the PRC HATED each other, and Vietnam hated China as well.

Lives would have been saved if Ho Chih Minh had been recognized as the leader of Vietnam instead of setting up the puppet governments in the South. Vietnam was NOT Korea, and still isn't. Vietnam could have been Asia's Yugoslavia, which was a HUGE thorn in Russia's side under Tito--and we quietly worked with him.
You can cite pretty much the same tale when it comes to Cuba, Nicaragua, Columbia, Iraq, Iran, Syria, Lebanon ...

We have often been our own worst enemy.
Not to mention Chile.
"Even if the bee could explain to the fly why pollen is better than shit, the fly could never understand."

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot] and 1 guest